My immediate apologies for the steady stream of acronyms immediately following this apology. But there’s no better way for this to be said than by co-opting the vernacular of mooks who love these acronyms right up until they’re applied to them.
What’s happening here is perhaps the most logical conclusion to everything the Trump DOJ has been doing since Trump took over the DOJ (for a second time!) following the 2024 elections. The MAGA boys were all about the FAFO as the administration flooded the zone with broken Overton windows and never ending attacks on the principles that actually make America great.
FAFO! these rubes gloated as masked kidnapping squads disappeared people into foreign torture prisons. FAFO! they gloated as the military started sinking boats and killing presumptively innocent people in international waters. FAFO! they blood-lustily hollered as immigration officers murdered American citizens and the Trump administration bombed Iran into…um… well, something pretty far from “submission (and the United States into insolvency).
FO is happening. It has been delayed but it’s as inevitable as a Thin Blue Line decal on a rolling coal truck. The DOJ has been in a constant state of Fuck Around with Trump in charge, abandoning any legitimate crime-fighting efforts to engage in vindictive prosecutions of Trump’s political does, devoted limited resources to Trump’s illegal deportation efforts, and then spend even more resources defending these illegal actions in court.
The courts have long recognized the “fucking around.” The zone is now constantly being flooded by the consequences of these actions by the administration. Tens of thousands of decisions have gone against the administration in immigration cases. The DOJ has been drained of personnel, forcing the few that remain to scuttle their own careers in hopes of… I don’t know… becoming part of Trump’s perennially unpaid legal reps following his exit from office.
How bad are things for DOJ lawyers? Maybe just ask AUSA Thomas Price, who has been just been evicted entirely by a federal judge in New York for, well… let’s not sugarcoat it… lying to the court.
On Monday, a federal district court judge barred a Department of Justice attorney from ever appearing again in a particular case, and promised to review whether two other Department attorneys would suffer a similar fate. In the case, Benitez v. Department of Homeland Security, the plaintiffs allege that federal immigration officers operating in New York have engaged in a practice of arresting people on the basis of their ethnicity and without obtaining required warrants.
In a hearing on Monday before issuing the sanction, U.S. District Judge Sanket J. Bulsara of the Eastern District of New York said the Justice Department’s letter to the court on Nov. 4, 2026 grossly misrepresented the scope of an injunction in another case. Judge Bulsara said Assistant U.S. Attorney Thomas Price’s signed letter was done in “bad faith, a deliberate attempt to mislead the Court, perpetuate a fraud on the tribunal, and violate[s] obligations under Rule 11.”
That’s right, Judge Bulsar just called a Trump AUSA a bad faith liar who attempted to engage in fraud on the court. Those are extremely serious charges. The underlying case deals with the government’s ongoing refusal to stop engaging in stops and detentions that appears to based solely on the perceived racial makeup of those being stopped and detained. While Justice Kavanaugh did kind of say these sort of stops were probably just okay enough to avoid further discussion by this fully compromised version of the Supreme Court, lower courts aren’t nearly as willing to just paper over blatant racism with a few shaky analogies and a deliberate refusal to engage with the facts of the case.
Existing court orders forbade DHS components from performing these sorts of stops. The DHS simply pretended these orders didn’t exist. The DOJ stepped in to defend the DHS, only to find its actions couldn’t actually be defended. The letter [PDF] that resulted in AUSA Price being ejected from the court for the entirety of this litigation deliberately misrepresented the previous orders by the court. Unwisely, these misrepresentations were made in the same federal court jurisdiction that had previously barred the actions the DOJ lawyer now claimed were perfectly legal actions supported by court precedent.
Most specifically (and egregiously), the government (through AUSA Price) pretended an injunction forbidding the entirety of the federal government from engaging in racially biased stops only applied to the single complainant in a one of dozens of similar cases brought against the government in New York.
The injunction granted by Judge Gary Brown in May covered the entire district. The government refused to comply with it. And when asked why, the only explanation given was that it believed (conveniently) that it only applied to officers seeking to stop, detain, or arrest the plaintiff in the cited case, Sanchez Alfaro.
The judge expressed his disbelief and disgust in a brief conference with the DOJ’s lawyers:
“When I issued the order that I issued in this case, I actually did it fully expecting I was giving a gift horse to the respondents. Because it was my expectation and understanding that there were portions of the relief that the plaintiffs in this case were seeking had been moot because of the existence of an injunction that was already put in place. … so what I got back here was astounding. I was flabbergasted by the response.”
While multiple lawyers’ names appear in the letter, it’s AUSA Thomas Price’s signature on the bottom line. Consequently, Price is the first against the wall. The order issued by the court (via docket entry) makes it clear Price is persona non grata in perpetuity when it comes to this case. But it also makes it clear the ice that the rest of the DOJ’s lawyers are standing on is pretty fucking thin:
The Court orders and notes the following: 1. AUSA Price is barred from continuing appearances in this case and must file a notice of withdrawal no later than November 13, 2026. 2. Every future filing in this docket must be signed by Richard Hayes, Chief of the Civil Division of the U.S. Attorney’s Office for the Eastern District of New York, or someone at his supervisory level or higher. Submissions signed by other AUSAs will be rejected. 3. Mr. Hayes, or someone at his supervisory level or higher, must appear at every future hearing held by either the undersigned or Judge Wicks in this case. 4. Pursuant to Rule 11(c)(3), the U.S. Attorney’s Office is directed to show cause why Rule 11 sanctions should not be imposed or imposed pursuant to 28 U.S.C. § 1927 or the Court’s inherent power, based upon the concerns and preliminary findings made by the Court articulated on the record, by November 16, 2026. 5. The Court has issued a warning about the consequence should the Court discover any future misrepresentation or false statement (either by counsel or any witness or declarant): after an opportunity to be heard, should preliminary findings be confirmed, the Court will enter a default judgment in this case in favor of Plaintiffs, with the only issue for resolution to be remedies to be imposed.
Without a doubt, some idiots will claim these are the actions of an “activist judge” because no judge has ever done the same thing to DOJ lawyers prior to this point in history. Some of those idiots will undoubtedly hold federal cabinet positions. But the reason this sort of thing hasn’t happened before isn’t because there’s a sudden groundswell of activism by federal judges. It’s because the DOJ has never dared to behave this way prior to this point in history. And it’s solely because the DOJ has become little more than the personification of Trump’s worst impulses that it’s being routinely run out of court by the people who actually run the courts. And, as everyone has ever gloated ever, if you don’t like the “finding out,” maybe knock off all the “fucking around.”